Stories
I Became a Surrogate for My Sister & Her Husband — When They Saw the Baby, They Yelled, 'This Isn't the Baby We Expected'
November 27, 2024
A few days before my wedding, I went to grab a bottle of wine from the basement. But halfway down the stairs, I heard my mom whispering to my fiancé, "You should never marry her." Frozen at the top step, I listened as my mother exposed a secret I'd buried for years.
The final days before my wedding should have felt like a dream. Instead, they became something else entirely — like the slow, eerie shift in a song's key that you don't notice at first, but then you suddenly realize something sounds wrong.
A woman in her home | Source: Midjourney
Luke and I pulled into my parents' driveway just after five in the evening a few days before our wedding. The familiar creak of the front gate and the crunch of tires on gravel stirred up a swirl of nostalgia.
Everything about this place — the ivy on the front porch, the faint smell of roses from the garden — was home. Luke smiled at me as he put the car in park.
"Ready to argue over napkin colors with your mom?" he teased, eyes crinkling at the corners in that way that made my heart do ridiculous things.
A man smiling | Source: Midjourney
"Please. If she brings up blush versus dusty rose one more time, I'm eloping," I shot back, but I leaned over to kiss him, anyway. I could taste his spearmint gum, a taste so familiar and grounding.
Inside, Mom was already moving at warp speed, rattling off a list of "urgent" last-minute items from the to-do list while handing us clipboards like it was a boardroom meeting.
Dad hovered near the kitchen, wisely staying out of her way. It was all so normal. So safe.
Until it wasn't.
A worried woman | Source: Midjourney
"Jenna, can you run to the basement and grab a bottle of wine? Look for the one with the gold label," Mom called from the kitchen, not even looking up from the stack of seating charts. "It's the good stuff. We'll need it if we're gonna survive this."
"Sure, Mom," I replied, already halfway to the basement door.
I flipped the light switch at the top of the basement stairs. The fluorescent bulb hummed to life, buzzing faintly as the stairs stretched below me like a gaping mouth.
Basement staircase | Source: Pexels
Halfway down, I paused. A little voice in my head nagged at me. Had she said red or white? I didn't remember her specifying which type of wine she wanted.
Turning, I climbed back up, but as I reached the top of the stairs, I heard something that stopped me dead in my tracks.
Voices. Low hushed voices coming from the living room.
"... I'm begging you, Luke," my mom's voice said, strained but firm. "You have to call it off before it's too late. You should never marry her because…"
A woman standing on a basement staircase | Source: Midjourney
Silence.
I froze behind the door, my hand suspended in midair halfway to the doorknob. The world tilted sideways and my breath caught in my chest so hard it hurt.
Luke's voice came next, sharp and defensive. "What are you talking about? Why would you even say that?"
"Please, Luke," my mom whispered. "Believe me. I'll explain."
A stunned woman | Source: Midjourney
The world narrowed to that moment, to those two voices. My heart pounded against my ribs like it was trying to escape. Slowly, I inched closer. Close enough to hear everything.
Her voice dropped, quieter now but deadly clear. "When Jenna was sixteen, the doctors told her she wouldn't be able to have children." Her words were slow and deliberate like she was laying down bricks one by one.
"I know how much you want to be a father one day. You've talked about it all night. If you're not prepared for adoption or surrogacy, don't marry her. Please."
A woman standing on a basement staircase | Source: Midjourney
"It's been so difficult for Jenna to come to terms with this health issue," Mom continued. "She's already suffered so much… it will break her if you hurt her later because she can't have children."
The surrounding air seemed to press in, heavy and suffocating. My ears buzzed and my chest tightened.
How dare she!
An emotional woman | Source: Midjourney
Tears pricked my eyes as I stared at the closed door before me. The pleading and desperation in Mom's voice made it clear she was only trying to look out for me, but I felt so betrayed.
The health issues she was discussing with Luke were deeply personal, something she had no right to discuss with him. It was my secret to share, not hers! I'd been waiting for the right time to tell him, afraid of how he might take the news, but now Mom had told him everything.
An emotional woman | Source: Midjourney
I pressed my hand flat against the wall, steadying myself while waiting for Luke's response. I braced for it and dreaded it, but I had to hear what he would say.
Seconds stretched like hours. I stared at the floor, afraid to breathe, afraid to blink. Then, finally, he spoke. His voice was strong, every syllable hitting like a steady drumbeat.
"How could you think I'd love her any less because of this?" His words filled the room, unshakable and sure. "I don't care about having biological kids. I care about Jenna."
A woman in a basement | Source: Midjourney
There was another pause. When Luke spoke again, his voice was low but fierce. "We'll adopt or find a surrogate; it doesn't matter. We'll do whatever we need to do. Love is enough."
Love is enough.
I didn't realize I was crying until a tear hit my hand. My body moved before my brain could catch up. I stepped out of the shadows, every muscle in me quaking as I joined them in the room.
They both turned to look at me.
Two people caught off guard | Source: Midjourney
Luke's face softened instantly, his eyes filled with so much love that I almost broke in two. My mom's face went pale, and her mouth opened in shock.
"Jenna… I didn't mean…"
"Stop," I said, my voice brittle but steady. I walked closer, never looking away from them. "I heard everything."
Mom's eyes filled with tears, and she pressed her hands to her face like that would let her hide from it all.
A woman covering her face with her hands | Source: Midjourney
I turned to Luke first, my whole heart in my throat. "I was going to tell you. I just —"
"You don't have to explain," he said, crossing the room in three long strides. He pulled me in, wrapping me in his arms like armor. His chin rested on the top of my head. "You're enough for me. You've always been enough."
That's when I broke.
A woman crying | Source: Midjourney
I held on to him like he was the only thing keeping me upright as tears coursed down my face.
Over his shoulder, I saw my mom, crumpled on the couch, sobbing into her hands. Her whole body shook with it.
"I'm sorry," she choked out. "I was wrong. I thought I was protecting you, but I hurt you instead. I just — I couldn't stand the idea of someone breaking your heart because of something you have no power to change."
A pleading woman | Source: Midjourney
"I know you had good intentions, Mom, but you should've trusted Luke," I said softly. "And you should've trusted me, too."
Luke turned to face her, his arm still wrapped around me like a shield. His voice was calm but unyielding.
"Mrs. Carter, I understand you're scared. But I need you to know I'm not going anywhere." He took a breath, glancing at me, then back at her. "If we ever decide to adopt, that child will be loved as much as if we'd created them ourselves."
Two people speaking | Source: Midjourney
Her sobs grew quieter, smaller. She nodded, her face crumpling as she wiped her cheeks with both hands.
The wedding went on as planned.
We stood at the altar, Luke's hands holding mine, steady as ever. The pastor's voice was a hum in the background, like the low roll of distant thunder. But when Luke spoke his vows, everything else fell away.
A man getting married | Source: Midjourney
"In sickness and in health," he said, his voice as sure as it had been that night. "For better or for worse."
I felt every word like an anchor dropping into the deepest part of me. His eyes stayed on mine, steady and clear. I knew now, without a doubt, that he meant every word of those vows.
At the reception, my mom stood up to give a toast. Her fingers trembled around the champagne flute, and she cleared her throat twice before she spoke.
A woman giving a toast | Source: Midjourney
"I wasn't sure anyone would ever deserve my daughter," she said, her voice thick with emotion. She glanced at me, eyes brimming, and then back at Luke. "But I see it now. She deserves someone who loves her exactly the way you do."
Her voice cracked on the last word. Luke squeezed my hand. Tears filled my eyes, but this time, they didn't stem from hurt or fear.
They were something else entirely.
A teary-eyed woman | Source: Midjourney
All around us, there were quiet sniffles and soft gasps. Not a dry eye in the house.
My mom met my eyes, a smile pulling at her lips through the tears. It wasn't much, but we had all made it through.
And love was enough.
Here's another story: While cleaning my late father's desk, I found a hidden drawer containing a letter addressed to me. His words were tender — until they revealed a shocking secret he'd carried for years, one that changed everything I thought I knew about my life.
This work is inspired by real events and people, but it has been fictionalized for creative purposes. Names, characters, and details have been changed to protect privacy and enhance the narrative. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental and not intended by the author.
The author and publisher make no claims to the accuracy of events or the portrayal of characters and are not liable for any misinterpretation. This story is provided "as is," and any opinions expressed are those of the characters and do not reflect the views of the author or publisher.