My BF’s Daughter Wanted to Be His Only Princess Until I Realized Who Was Really Pulling the Strings — Story of the Day

I thought I’d found the perfect man until his daughter asked if I’d earned “enough points” to stay. At first, I smiled. But then I realized... someone was keeping score. And it wasn’t just her.

I met Zach completely by chance, standing in line for coffee. I was lost in a book when I heard a warm male voice behind me.

“Is the book better than the coffee? That’s rare among modern girls.”

I looked up and smiled. Standing there was a man with his own cute mug.

“I’m just rereading a classic. Trying to feel like a student again.”

“Classics are dangerous. They can suddenly make you realize you’re living the wrong life. I’m Zach, by the way.”

“Mia.”

Then Zach handed his card to the barista.

“Her latte’s on me. For the intellect.”

That’s how it all began. One random latte turned into long walks, silly taco dinners in bed, and movie nights at retro cinemas.

Zach always brought something thoughtful: sometimes my favorite breakfast in a box or tickets to an old film I’d only mentioned. I teased him once.

“Are you secretly taking notes on everything I say?”

“Only the important stuff. Like the fact you hate roses but adore tulips,” Zach replied, handing me a bouquet of sunshine-yellow tulips.

He truly listened. Not just nodded — listened. And I, a woman who’d once been badly burned, finally allowed myself to believe in “maybe.”

We dated for six months. No drama, no games. Just… good. Until one evening, while we were sitting on a bench by the river, he took my hand.

“I haven’t thought about anything serious in a long time... But with you, it’s different. And now... I want you to meet my daughter, Emma.”

I froze for a second. His daughter. Yes, I knew she existed... but we had never really talked about her.

“Why didn’t you ever tell me about her before?”

Zach sighed.

“Emma’s my princess. I needed to be sure this was real. And now I am. So… if you’re okay with it, I want to take the next step.”

“It means a lot that you’re ready for that.”

“She lives with her mom but often stays with me on weekends. I'm thinking about living together someday, so it’s time you two met.”

“I’m a little surprised, not gonna lie. But I’m not against it. I want to know that part of your life.”

That weekend, we went to the park — Zach, his little “princess,” and myself. Emma turned out to be sweet. Shy, polite, and quiet. We fed the ducks, laughed, and played a board game on the grass.

I bought her an ice cream, and as she licked the bright pink scoop, she giggled,

“This is better than the kind Dad buys.”

I laughed too.

“Well, I’ve always had a flawless taste in ice cream things.”

Emma smiled for the first time. And I thought, maybe we'd really get along. Later, in the car, when Emma had fallen asleep in the back seat, Zach gently squeezed my hand.

“I know it’s still early… But maybe you could move in? Emma likes you.”

“Let's try.”

Everything felt too perfect. Zach. Our relationship. Even Emma. I truly believed that was the beginning of our new family. That’s what I thought…

Until we started living under the same roof.

***

Moving in with Zach felt warm, almost festive. We carried boxes, arranged my books, and tried to assemble my beanbag chair. I felt wanted. Loved. Like I truly belonged.

And then Emma arrived with a panda-print suitcase and a twisted expression when she saw my robe hanging on the bathroom hook.

“We always had a towel with duckies...”

She said it quietly, but loud enough for me to hear it clearly. That’s when it all began. With little things.

“Daddy, don’t I look better with curls than Sophie?”

“You’re always beautiful, sweetheart.”

At first, I laughed it off, thinking it was just her age and a little jealousy. But then… out of nowhere, the scoring system appeared.

“Sophie gets 7 points today for the gift. But she didn’t let me have candy before dinner... So, minus 3. That’s 4.”

She said it out loud, clearly and proudly, right in front of Zach. And he just smiled, as if it were some cute little game.

Emma judged everything—my clothes, my hairstyle, even how I set the table.

“Mom always sets it differently.”

“Mom smells better.”

“Mom lets me watch cartoons in the morning.”

I tried to talk to her. Gently. Kindly. With love. But every move I made was under her microscope.

That evening, while I was setting the table, I couldn’t take it anymore.

“Zach, we need to talk.”

He put his napkin down and sat across from me.

“What’s wrong, love?”

“You’ve noticed Emma constantly rates me, right? She compares me to your ex, gives me scores... and you just... ignore it. Like it’s normal.”

He sighed.

“Sophie… she’s just a child. It’s hard for her. New home, new rules. She’s trying to adjust.”

“This isn’t adjusting. This is manipulation. She knows exactly how to get to you.”

“Give her some time. You know she loves you. It’s just... complicated right now.”

I nodded. But something chilled inside me. That was more than childish games. I could feel it.

After dinner, we had planned a cozy night: pillows, popcorn, movies, soft lighting. It was our first anniversary since we met.

I waited for Zach on the couch while he tucked Emma in. But when he returned... Well, he wasn’t alone.

Emma walked in with him, eyes big and deliberately sad.

“Daddy, I’m scared... Can I sleep with you? Like before?..”

Zach looked at me with an apologetic smile.

“Love, do you mind? Emma’s feeling really sensitive tonight…”

I barely held back. “But... we planned this evening together. And... it’s our anniversary.”

“Oh, sweetheart… We’ll go to the movies tomorrow. I promise.”

“Minus five points!” Emma shouted, already crawling under the blanket. “Time for you to go to bed, Sophie.”

I stood there, not believing what I was hearing.

“But... the guest room is still under renovation…”

“You can sleep in my bed!” Emma shouted with a mouth full of popcorn.

An hour later, I was lying in her bed. Stuffed bears. Dolls. Fairy lights. The scent of strawberry lotion. A unicorn-patterned blanket. I couldn’t sleep. I couldn’t breathe.

I felt like a guest in a dollhouse, waiting to be politely asked to leave. I was trying to fluff the pillow to get comfortable when I suddenly noticed something under Emma’s pillow.

A crumpled piece of paper. The handwriting was clearly not a child’s.

LITTLE REMINDERS FOR WHEN YOU'RE WITH DADDY

1. Always be Daddy’s number one

2. Sleep in Daddy’s bed

3. Give Sophie scores

4. Compare Sophie to Mom

REMEMBER:

If something doesn’t go your way — CRY. Daddy will do anything for you. Kisses, Mom

I sat at the edge of the bed. The paper trembled in my fingers.

Oh God... This wasn’t just a jealous little girl acting out. This was planned. Taught. Rehearsed. Every tear. Every “minus point.” It wasn’t just Emma. It was her mother, pulling every string.

And then...

“Sophie?..”

I looked up. Emma was standing in the doorway. She was staring straight at me. And at the crumpled note in my hands.

***

The following morning, Emma didn’t say a word. She avoided me, didn’t meet my eyes. I tried to start a conversation, but she always looked away. That silence was the most unsettling thing of all.

I wanted to talk to Zack. I had to tell him everything. I carried that note in my pocket all morning, waiting for the right moment.

And in the afternoon, I finally walked toward his office, ready to speak. But just as I passed by Emma’s room, I heard her muffled voice through the door:

“Mom, please... You promised to come to my recital. I’m scared… There are lights, a stage, people watching...”

Silence. Then came her mother’s voice on the speaker:

“You’re a big girl now, Emma. Big girls don’t whine. You know what to do — stay close to Daddy. Stick to the list.”

I froze.

“But I just wanted you to be there…”

“There? If you can’t convincingly play the daughter who wants her family back, I have no reason to be there. I was clear.”

Click.

The call ended.

I stood there, motionless, when the floor creaked beneath my foot. Emma heard it and stepped into the hallway. Her face was pale. That wasn’t a jealous little girl playing games. That was a child trained to perform.

“Please don’t tell Daddy,” she whispered, tears gathering. “He won’t love me if he finds out…”

“Oh, sweetheart,” I said softly, kneeling in front of her. “I’m your friend. And Daddy is too. You don’t have to pretend anymore.”

Her lip trembled. “I... I’m scared of the recital. And now Mom’s not coming…”

I took her hand.

“I’m so sorry. Do you want me to come with you?”

“I do.”

***

The following day was the recital. Zack was delayed at work, so it was just me and Emma.

She stood near the entrance of the auditorium, wearing the same green dress her mom had picked for her, her shoulders stiff, head low. She looked so small. I walked up gently and put a hand on her back.

“Hey, Emma. How are you holding up?”

“Mom didn’t come…”

“I know you wanted her there. But I’m here for you. I believe in you.”

She didn’t say thank you. She just nodded. And went inside.

The performance was beautiful. Zack arrived just in time — flowers in hand, pride in his eyes. But Emma didn’t run to him. She ran to me and hugged me. For the first time.

“Sophie… I know you saw the list. I didn’t want to do it… But Mom said if I didn’t, she wouldn’t…”

I held her tighter.

“You’re safe now. I’m with you. And this is not your fault.”

At that moment, she was just a child clinging to any kind of love she could hold on to.

Zack came closer, concern in his eyes.

“Sweetheart? What is it?”

That’s when Emma told him everything. The list. The rules. The comparisons. Her mother’s words. The pressure. Zack didn’t speak right away. He simply wrapped her in his arms.

“You are not to blame. For any of it.”

When he looked at me, I saw it: more than gratitude. There was trust. A deep, unspoken kind.

***

Later that week, Emma moved in with us — her choice. Her mother didn’t object. I knew that was only the beginning.

She wasn’t just “my boyfriend’s daughter” anymore.

She was our daughter.

And I was ready to help her learn how to feel safe. How to be loved. For real this time.

Tell us what you think about this story and share it with your friends. It might inspire them and brighten their day.

If you enjoyed this story, read this one: I took a waitressing job behind my husband’s back to make my son’s birthday dream come true. Then my mother-in-law showed up and made sure I’d never forget that night. Read the full story here.

This piece is inspired by stories from the everyday lives of our readers and written by a professional writer. Any resemblance to actual names or locations is purely coincidental. All images are for illustration purposes only. Share your story with us; maybe it will change someone’s life. If you would like to share your story, please send it to info@amomama.com.