A Thief Had Been Stealing from My Store for Weeks, and When I Finally Caught Him, I Found a Photo of Myself in His Wallet – Story of the Day

Running a grocery store in a quiet neighborhood, I never imagined theft would become part of my life. Yet for weeks, items disappeared without a trace. I set a trap, expecting answers. Instead, the thief’s wallet revealed a faded photograph—my own face staring back.

I spent most days behind the counter of my small grocery store, watching people come and go.

Couples came in holding hands, choosing ingredients for dinner together, parents shopped with their kids tugging at their sleeves, and groups of friends laughed as they debated over snacks.

I often told myself I had no regrets, that I had built this store with my own hands, and that it was enough. But that was a lie.

The truth was, the only regret that really mattered was never having a family. In my younger years, I thought I was too good for commitment.

I had a temper, a sharp tongue, and an arrogance that pushed people away. I thought there would always be time later to change, to settle down.

But “later” had turned into years, and now, I was just a man in his late forties with no one waiting for him at home.

The only thing I had was that store. So when I started noticing that products were missing, it shook me more than I expected. At first, I thought it was a mistake. Maybe I had miscounted.

But day by day, the empty spaces on the shelves grew more obvious. Cans, bread, milk, small things, but enough to matter.

The thought of someone stealing felt like a personal attack. And in this neighborhood? It didn’t make sense.

Yet my mind kept circling back to one person, Margaret. She was an older woman who lived a few blocks away.

Everyone knew she lived alone, and I never saw anyone helping her.

It seemed possible she might be taking food because she couldn’t afford it. The thought didn’t make me angry. If anything, I felt sorry for her.

When she came into the store the next day, I decided to ask, carefully, just to be sure. She was looking at the bread aisle when I approached her.

“Margaret, can I ask you something?”

“What is it?”

“It’s just… some items have gone missing lately. And I wondered if maybe… you’ve been taking things without paying. If you’re in need, you could have told me. I’d help you.”

Her face hardened instantly, and her voice rose so loud that the few other customers turned their heads.

“How dare you! How dare you accuse me of stealing!”

“I didn’t mean...”

“I spent my entire life as a surgeon saving people’s lives. I worked myself to the bone, and now some miserable shopkeeper thinks I’m a thief? You should be ashamed!”

“I was only asking because...”

“Because you’re rude! Because you have no respect!”

And before I could react, she swung her handbag at me, hitting me in the chest. My breath caught in shock as she stormed past me, muttering insults until the door slammed behind her.

Shame burned in me, even though all I wanted was to help. But even as I tried to convince myself to forget it, the shelves told me otherwise.

The products were still disappearing. Whatever the truth was, it wasn’t going away.

***

One night, I made up my mind: I would buy security cameras and install an alarm system. Trust wasn’t enough anymore.

For a few days after installing the cameras and alarm, everything looked normal. The shelves stayed full, and I convinced myself that maybe the problem had ended.

***

But a week later, when I unlocked the store in the morning, I saw the same gaps again: boxes of cereal, some fruit, a pack of meat. The alarm had never gone off.

I rushed to the back office and pulled up the recordings. Around midnight, the door opened, and a hooded figure slipped inside.

The person moved with purpose, never hesitating, collecting food as if they knew exactly what they wanted.

What unsettled me most was how calmly the thief reset the alarm before walking out. They hadn’t triggered a single sensor.

Leaning toward the screen, I tried to catch a glimpse of a face, but the hood stayed low, and every turn kept their back to the cameras.

It felt deliberate, as if they knew where every lens was. That thought gnawed at me. No one should have known the code or the placement of the cameras.

The longer I stared, the clearer it became; whoever that was, they weren’t just lucky. They understood my store almost as well as I did. And that left me with only one choice: I had to see them myself.

That evening, I closed the store at the usual time, making sure to flick off the lights like always. But instead of leaving, I circled back and slipped inside through the rear door, locking it quietly behind me.

My heart thudded in my chest as I crouched behind the counter, waiting.

The silence was heavy, broken only by the hum of the refrigerators. I told myself to stay alert, but exhaustion pressed down on me, and before I knew it, my eyes had closed.

A noise snapped me awake. The front door creaked open, and soft footsteps echoed through the aisles.

I held my breath, my palms sweating. The thief had come back. Slowly, I peered over the counter.

The figure moved inside, bag in hand, repeating the same routine I had seen on the tape. I stepped out slowly, my heart hammering, and crept up behind them.

At the right moment, I reached forward and grabbed the sleeve of the hoodie.

The thief spun around, and I froze. A boy, no older than fifteen, stared at me with terrified eyes.

“What are you doing in my store?” I demanded.

“Let me go!” he shouted, struggling against me.

“Not until you tell me who you are. What’s your name? Where are you from?”

“I said, let me go!”

“Listen, kid, you can’t just steal from people. Talk to me. Who are you?”

When he refused to speak, I reached into his pocket, hoping to find some kind of ID, a wallet, anything that could tell me who he was.

My fingers closed around a small wallet, and I pulled it out. Inside, behind a few crumpled bills, was a photo, my face, younger, but unmistakably me.

I stared at the picture, then back at the boy. “Where did you get this?”

“Give it back!” he shouted, trying to snatch it from me.

“Tell me where you got it!” I pressed, but he tore free from my loosened grip, bolted to the door, and was gone.

By the time I reached the street, he was already on his bike, disappearing into the night.

I stood alone in the store, the photo trembling in my hand. The boy’s terrified eyes haunted me, but it was the younger version of myself in that picture that wouldn’t let me breathe.

I barely slept that night. The image of the boy’s face and that old photo of me kept circling in my head.

By morning, I knew I couldn’t ignore it. I had to find him.

The wallet held almost nothing, just five dollars and the photo.

No ID, no name. It felt like a dead end until a regular customer noticed me staring at the picture behind the counter.

“Hey, I know that place,” he said, pointing at the background. “That’s by the lake, near the old houses.”

His words hit me like a spark. I suddenly remembered the day that photo was taken. I knew exactly who had snapped it, and the realization made my chest tighten.

Without another word, I closed the store early, told the few shoppers to come back tomorrow, and locked the door behind me.

Driving out to the lake felt like stepping back into a past I had avoided for years. The houses looked worn down now, paint peeling, roofs sagging.

When I stopped in front of one, something inside me said I’d found the right place.

I knocked on the door, and when it opened, the same boy stood there. His eyes went wide, and before I could speak, he slammed the door in my face.

I knocked again, harder that time.

The door opened slowly, and a thin woman appeared, leaning against the frame. Her face was pale, her shoulders fragile, but I knew her instantly. Laura.

“Michael?” she whispered.

I just blurted out the one question clawing at me.

“Is he… is that boy my son?”

“You don’t get to ask that. You made your choice fifteen years ago.”

“I was an idiot,” I said quickly. “I was scared. I didn’t know what I was doing.”

“You told me you hadn’t finished living your life, that I wasn’t worth your time. And then you left me.”

“I regretted it every single day. I pushed you away because it felt too real, too much for me. I was a coward.”

Laura’s lips trembled, but she shook her head. “It’s too late. You don’t belong here anymore.”

“Did you know you were pregnant when I left?”

She closed her eyes for a moment.

“I found out two weeks later.”

“And what would you have done, Michael? Back then, you didn’t care. And now? Now we don’t need you. We’ve managed on our own.”

“It doesn’t look like you’ve managed all that well. That boy has been stealing from me. If you were fine, he wouldn’t need to risk that.”

Laura’s eyes widened in shock.

“Stealing? Ethan?”

The name hit me like a punch. Ethan. My son.

“She’s sick! And you never cared! You never cared about either of us!”

Laura stiffened but said nothing. The door closed again, and that time she didn’t answer when I knocked. After a long moment, I turned and walked back to my car.

But the thought wouldn’t leave me alone.

That night, I drove back. I carried boxes from the trunk, empty for now, but heavy with meaning. I knocked again. Laura opened the door, her face weary.

“Why are you here again?” she asked.

“To do what I should have done fifteen years ago. To take care of my son. To take care of both of you.”

Her eyes searched mine, doubtful, almost angry.

I went on. “Pack your things. Both of you. Come with me. I can’t change the past, but I can be here now.”

For a long moment, she stood frozen. Then, slowly, she opened the door wider.

Inside, Ethan’s eyes narrowed as he watched me step into their home.

I knew it would take time, maybe years, to earn even a shred of his trust.

But at least now I had the chance.

Tell us what you think about this story and share it with your friends. It might inspire them and brighten their day.

If you enjoyed this story, read this one: I had everything planned for our first anniversary. The perfect surprise, a romantic dinner at the restaurant where we first met. But then, just as I was preparing, my husband’s phone lit up with a message from "Baby." What was he hiding from me? Read the full story here.

This piece is inspired by stories from the everyday lives of our readers and written by a professional writer. Any resemblance to actual names or locations is purely coincidental. All images are for illustration purposes only. Share your story with us; maybe it will change someone’s life. If you would like to share your story, please send it to info@amomama.com.