I Inherited My Mother’s House Only to Discover Someone Was Already Living in the Attic — Story of the Day

When I inherited my mother’s house, I expected to find memories, not mysteries. But on the second night, strange noises led me to the attic. Among cobwebs and dust, I found a child’s teddy bear. At that moment, I realized I wasn’t alone in the house.

When I inherited my mother’s house, it felt like stepping into a memory wrapped in bittersweet nostalgia. The small town, with its sleepy streets and whispering trees, used to feel like home. After years in the bustling chaos of the city, its silence pressed against me.

“I don’t know how I’m going to do this, Mom,” I said aloud as I stood in her living room.

The figurines on the shelf stared back at me. Her collection was still there—delicate porcelain pieces, each one a story. I traced my finger along the shelf, stopping at the empty spot where the small rooster used to sit.

“Where did it go?” I muttered, crouching to peer under the cabinet. “It has to be here somewhere.”

The idea of something missing from her beloved collection unsettled me more than I wanted to admit.

That night, the unease only grew. As I lay in bed, the silence of the house was too oppressive. The creak of floorboards above me made me sit up straight.

“No way,” I whispered, gripping the blanket. Then came the shuffle—a faint, deliberate sound that made my heart race.

“Probably just the house settling,” I told myself.

Morning brought more questions than answers. I opened the fridge to grab breakfast and frowned.

“Didn’t I just buy a full loaf of bread?” I stared at the remaining slices. The milk carton felt suspiciously light, too.

“Okay, Emma. Get it together. You’re just tired.”

But I wasn’t convinced. By afternoon, curiosity got the better of me. I climbed the narrow attic stairs, each step creaking under my weight. The smell of dust hit me first, but then I saw it. A corner of the attic that looked strangely lived-in.

“What…?” I crouched down, picking up a small, threadbare teddy bear.

Wrappers from candy bars and yogurt lids littered the floor. My heart pounded as I looked around the dim space.

“Who’s been up here?” I whispered, holding the bear tightly.

Someone had been here. Maybe still was.

Oh, no. No, no, no.

I backed out of the attic, clutching the bear, every hair on my neck standing on end.

What is going on in this house?

***

On the second night, I was ready. My nerves were stretched tight. Whoever or whatever was in this house needed to show themselves.

I arranged some items in the kitchen: a loaf of bread, a couple of apples, and a jar of peanut butter. They weren’t much, but they’d be enough to tempt someone hungry. Then I waited, flashlight in hand, perched on the edge of my bed like a cat ready to pounce.

When the clock struck midnight, I heard it. A faint creak in the hallway.

My pulse quickened. I held my breath, every muscle in my body taut. Then came another sound—a quiet shuffle, almost like bare feet against the wooden floor.

I slipped off the bed and tiptoed toward the door, gripping the flashlight tightly.

Stay calm, Emma. Just see what it is.

The noises led me to the kitchen. Peering around the corner, I clicked on the flashlight, the beam slicing through the darkness. There he was.

A small boy sat at the table, biting the whole loaf of bread. He froze when the light hit him, his wide eyes locking onto mine.

“Who are you?” I asked softly, trying not to startle him.

He didn’t answer. His chest rose and fell rapidly, and his tiny hands trembled as they hovered near the bread. He didn’t even try to run.

I took a cautious step closer, lowering the flashlight so it wasn’t shining directly in his face.

“It’s okay,” I said gently. “I’m not going to hurt you.”

“Please don’t send me back,” he whispered.

“Send you back where?” I crouched down to his level, trying to meet his eyes, but he looked away. “Are you lost? Do you live around here?”

He shook his head. His clothes were dirty and he looked exhausted and scared. I stood slowly and gestured toward the table. “Why don’t you sit down? You look like you need something to eat.”

I made him a sandwich and poured a glass of milk, watching as he devoured it like he hadn’t eaten in days.

“What’s your name?”

“Alex,” he mumbled between bites.

“Well, Alex, I’m Emma.”

Who is this boy? Why is he here?

After he finished eating, I led him to the living room. I handed him a blanket, and he curled up on the couch and fell asleep within minutes.

Once he was settled, I reached for his backpack, curiosity overriding my hesitation. Inside, I found a few mismatched items—a toy car, a notebook with scribbled drawings, and then… my breath caught.

The missing porcelain rooster!

I stared at it, the fragile figurine somehow more significant now that it had been found in his possession.

Why did he take this? What does it mean to him?

I sat in the dark, holding the figurine and watching Alex’s tiny frame rise and fall with each breath. This wasn’t just a boy stealing food. He was tangled in something much bigger. And now, so was I.

***

The next morning, as sunlight streamed through the curtains, I heard a sharp knock at the door. My heart sank. I wasn’t expecting anyone, and after the events of the past two nights, I wasn’t ready for more surprises.

Peeking through the window, I saw John, my neighbor. My stomach twisted. Our first interaction hadn’t exactly been warm. He complained about the noise from my moving truck and hadn’t even offered to lend a hand.

But at that moment, he stood on my porch.

I opened the door cautiously. “John?”

“Morning,” he said. His eyes darted behind me, scanning the room. “I, uh, need to talk to you about something important.”

I stepped aside reluctantly, letting him in. He wasted no time.

“I’m looking for a boy,” he began, his tone impatient. “Alex. He’s been missing for a few days. I’m his guardian.”

“Alex?” I repeated, glancing toward the living room, where the boy was still curled up on the couch.

“Yes. Alex has this habit of running off.” John sighed dramatically. “Have you seen him?”

I hesitated, my fingers gripping the edge of the door. I didn’t trust John’s tone, but I couldn’t lie. Slowly, I nodded and gestured toward the couch.

“He’s here. He showed up a couple of nights ago.”

John’s eyes lit up with irritation. He strode into the living room and yanked the blanket off Alex.

“There you are!” he snapped.

Alex blinked, confused and terrified.

“No! I don’t want to go!” he cried.

“Come on, we’re leaving,” John barked, taking Alex by the hand.

“Wait...” I stepped forward, unsure of what to say or do.

Every instinct screamed at me to stop this, but legally, what power did I have?

Alex’s eyes darted around the room, desperate. Then he spotted the porcelain rooster on the table.

“Grandma Sarah!” he shouted, reaching for it.

I grabbed the figurine before he could, holding it tightly to my chest. “Alex, wait...”

John barely looked back as he disappeared with Alex out the door. The boy’s cries echoed in the hallway, and then the door slammed shut.

My legs gave out, and I sank onto the couch, still clutching the figurine. My mind raced.

Grandma Sarah? How does he know her name?

I turned the rooster over in my hands, desperate for answers. That’s when I noticed a small opening at its base. Curious, I tugged at it and pulled out a folded piece of paper. My hands trembled as I opened it.

It was a letter, written in my mother’s familiar handwriting.

Tears blurred my vision as I read.

My mother had written about Alex: how he’d come to her whenever he ran away from John. She’d cared for him, fed him, and even dreamed of adopting him. But she had uncovered the truth: John only kept Alex for the state payments, neglecting him otherwise.

The final lines of the letter pierced my heart:

“Emma, if you’re reading this, please help Alex. I couldn’t finish what I started, but maybe you can. You don’t have to adopt him, just protect him.”

I clutched the letter to my chest, tears streaming down my face. I realized, at that moment, that the responsibility was mine now. My mother had trusted me to do what was right. And I couldn’t let her down.

***

I knew the letter alone wouldn’t be enough to protect Alex, but the weight of responsibility pressed hard on my shoulders. I had to act.

The next morning, I grabbed a notebook and started visiting the neighbors. Knocking on doors felt strange in a town I’d once called home, but people were kind enough to talk. Many of them remembered Alex.

“I’ve seen that boy always outside alone. It’s not right,” Mrs. Whitaker said, shaking her head. She lived two doors down from John.

Another neighbor, Mr. Jameson, frowned as he described Alex’s situation. “I heard John yelling at him last week. It breaks your heart, doesn’t it?”

Each conversation filled my audio recorder with more proof. The image of Alex’s life with John became clearer.

A few days later, I called CPS. My hands shook as I handed over the audio recorder and my mother’s letter. The CPS's representative, a serious woman named Ms. Garcia, listened intently as I explained everything.

“Thank you for bringing this to our attention,” she said. “We’ll investigate immediately.”

The next few days were a blur of waiting and hoping. I replayed the sound of Alex’s voice in my mind, his small hands clutching at the figurine, and his terrified plea: “Please don’t send me back.”

When CPS finally arrived at John’s house, I stood by the window, watching. The sight of them walking Alex to their car brought a flood of relief and tears. That night, I learned Alex would be temporarily placed in my care (just as I asked) while the investigation unfolded.

Those first few weeks with Alex were a whirlwind. He was shy and quiet at first, but little by little, he started to open up. We played board games at the kitchen table and made spaghetti together.

Months later, the court granted me permanent guardianship. On Alex’s seventh birthday, I sat across from him at the dining table, holding a wrapped box in my hands.

“Go on,” I said, smiling. “It’s for you.”

He tore through the paper, revealing a new plush teddy bear with a red bow.

“Thank you, Emma,” he whispered, hugging me tightly.

At that moment, I knew we were no longer two lost souls. We were a family. And somewhere, I was sure my mother was proudly smiling at me from above.

Tell us what you think about this story, and share it with your friends. It might inspire them and brighten their day.

If you enjoyed this story, read this one: Inheriting Grandma’s duplex should’ve been straightforward. Amanda got the second floor, and I got the first, with the garden and pool. But the house held a secret neither of us was ready for. Read the full story here.

This piece is inspired by stories from the everyday lives of our readers and written by a professional writer. Any resemblance to actual names or locations is purely coincidental. All images are for illustration purposes only. Share your story with us; maybe it will change someone’s life. If you would like to share your story, please send it to info@amomama.com.